Tuesday, January 04, 2005

Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem

We are finally talking about the plague of forged Israelite documents, and we should be. Sunlight is a powerful disinfectant.

But I think the real problem might go deeper. Because there is a fundamental difficulty in the way we imagine, and thereby attempt to dig up, ancient Israel. Because of both historical facts and inherent conceptual problems, this enterprise might be doomed to fail in the terms it has set itself. As long as the burning desire to authenticate or falsify Biblical documents exists, as long as the debate is cast in these terms, problems like this will continue to come up. So another question we could ask is, why is the debate cast in these terms, of maximalism vs. minimalism, history vs. ideology, authenticity vs. forgery? Why is the question we're so fixated on--how did it get to be this way--and is this quest somehow already set up for failure?

First of all, the ancient side of the problem: archaeology has not recovered the stark opposition between Israelites and others that the Biblical text proclaims. Excavations show that Syro-Palestinian material culture varied mainly by region and not ethnicity: Indeed, scholarship now views ethnic group membership as a result of deliberate choice and reflection by the members themselves, as well as others who recognize them. This is the crucial methodological contribution of Ian Hodder’s Symbols in Action, a series of studies in which archaeologists interpreted the recent material remains of a culture while the natives were still around to talk to. Able to ask what the excavated objects actually meant to their users, Hodder found that the ethnic significance of objects was determined in conversation and interaction, not set in stone, nor inherent in the things themselves. In other words, the bare physical forms of the artifacts were not as important as the ethnic interpretation their users gave them through language.

This goes against the long-standing “Culture Area” assumption that ethnic and linguistic divisions should line up with material culture--that we could dig up Israel as a tight, coherent national unit, which would correspond with people who, uniformly, spoke Hebrew, were members of an Israelite religion, believed in Davidic monarchy, and thought their ancestors came from Egypt. But Hodder’s theory has been borne out in Syro-Palestinian archaeology by studies of the distribution of items that were once thought to be taxonomically Israelite, such as the legendary four-room house and collar-rim jar. The spread of these items into places like Jordan correlates with geography and economy, not political or ethnic boundaries.

In a crucial recent article, Elizabeth Bloch-Smith points out that “not a single ‘Israelite’ trait identified by proponents of the Culture Area approach—pillared houses, collar-rim store jars, or pig abstinence--was exclusive to a conservatively delimited Iron I highland Israel…In general, Iron I highland architecture, diet, material culture, subsistence adaptation, language, and even cultic features continued Late Bronze Age practices or were attested in neighboring regions.”

The issue is not that the Culture Area approach did not produce the expected result here; the issue is that the result it expects is the excavation of a nation. Both rooted in and working to reinforce a distinctly modern concept--a tightly defined, homogenous nation-state, this archaeology’s “methods appeared to enable a clear-cut territorial boundary to be drawn around discrete culture assemblages, thereby delimiting the object of study as that of a distinct ethnic culture.” As the scholar of Nationalism Anthony Smith writes, this “presentation of a highly concrete and bounded territorial, archaeological culture seemed destined to clinch the nationalist image of a world of discrete and unique nations, each occupying an historic homeland, and each possessing its own shared memories and public culture, single economy and common laws.”

I should be clear: I don't see much purpose in asking whether an ancient Israel (as well as an ancient Judah, and an ancient Ephriam, which is what ancient Judeans like to call those northerners presumptuous enough to claim to be "Israel"!) existed. The question I'm excited about pursuing is whether it existed on our terms, and, especially, how you could recover the way it existed on their terms. The point of my book is to explore this through ancient writing. Provenanced ancient writing!

Last installment: the modern side of the problem, or, how it got this way.


Further Reading

Bloch-Smith, “Israelite Ethnicity in Iron I: Archaeology Preserves what is Remembered and what is Forgotten in Israel’s History” JBL 122 (2003) 401-25. The quote comes from p. 411

John S. Holladay, “Four-Room House” in Eric M. Meyers, ed. The Oxford Encylopedia of Archaeology in the Near East, vol. 2 (New York: Oxford University Press; 1997) 337-342

Hodder, Symbols in Action: Ethnoarchaeological Studies of Material Culture (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982)

A.D. Smith, “Authenticity, Antiquity and Archaeology” in Nations and Nationalism 7 (2002). The the quote comes from p. 442

37 comments:

Anonymous said...

you have an interesting blog fount the info very usefulI i have a abs diet site. Its full of useful abs diet related stuff.
come and check it out if you get chance
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Anonymous said...

Great site for people who like free weight loss diet.

Click here to see about free weight loss diet related stuff.

Thanks

free weight loss diet

Anonymous said...

If you know anyone interested in nutrition pregnancy, have them stop by my site.

People who study nutrition pregnancy tend to enjoy this program.

Anonymous said...

Interesting blog you have here, I landed here on accident. I like the title of Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem I was searching for something else and came across your site. I found it pretty interesting and entertaining. I got you book marked.

I will pop back in from time to time to see what you have new here.

I've got a new site up which might to be of interest to some. I run a herbal penis enlargement related site.

Anonymous said...

Shop online today. Forget driving to the mall when you can just click the mouse and order from your favorite store. No traffic to deal with

Anonymous said...

Your blog is perfect and nice, we are offering premature ejaculation help to learn more visit premature ejaculation help or Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html
premature ejaculation help http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html

Anonymous said...

Your blog is perfect and nice, we are offering to learn more visit or Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html
http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html

Anonymous said...

Hey, you sure have a nice site here with some very interesting stuff. I have already bookmarked it.

It's a shame I spend so much time blog surfing that I often forget my own. Crazy me. :) But its so addictive and fun.

Anyway, a lot of people are trying to make cash online nowadays, so I thought I'd help you out with a site that has some great tools.

whole penis enlargement
Not bad to sit around doing nothing while your bank balance keeps growing. :)

Anonymous said...

I have a similar website tied to penis enlargement men Come by some time.
I absolutely fancy your website, It's bookmarked! This information is fine stuff.

Anonymous said...

Your blog is great If you ever need penis enlargement technique related stuff, I'm sure you'd be interested in penis enlargement technique

Anonymous said...

I skim a lot of blogs, and so far yours is in the Top 3 of my list of favorites. I'm going to dive in and try my hand at it, so wish me luck.

I've got a site you might be interested in (mine is about discount penis enlargement ) I know, it sounds strange, but it's like anything, once you learn more about it, it's pretty cool. It's mostly about discount penis enlargement related articles and subjects.

Anonymous said...

Your blog is perfect and nice, we are offering premature ejaculation treatment to learn more visit premature ejaculation treatment or Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html
premature ejaculation treatment http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html

Anonymous said...

I have a similar website tied to penis pills Come by some time.
I very much fancy your site, I bookmarked it! This information is terrific stuff.

Anonymous said...

Your blog is perfect and nice, we are offering stop premature ejaculation to learn more visit stop premature ejaculation or Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html
stop premature ejaculation http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html

Anonymous said...

Your blog is perfect and nice, we are offering male ejaculation to learn more visit male ejaculation or Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html
male ejaculation http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html

Anonymous said...

Your blog is perfect and nice, we are offering female ejaculation to learn more visit female ejaculation or Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html
female ejaculation http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html

Anonymous said...

Your blog is perfect and nice, we are offering stop premature ejaculation to learn more visit stop premature ejaculation or Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html
stop premature ejaculation http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html

Anonymous said...

Your blog is perfect and nice, we are offering premature ejaculation cure to learn more visit premature ejaculation cure or Biblical Archaeology from Scratch II: The Real Problem http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html
premature ejaculation cure http://www.manifestingpower.com/premature-ejaculation.html

Anonymous said...

Hey Blogger,

The graphics/information/navigation on your site made my visit a worthwhile and pleasant one. I hate too much scrolling down pages and pages of information before I find what I am looking for but your site was easy to read and also very, very useful. Please keep up the good work!

Regards,
filter descrambler digital

Anonymous said...

Personally I do not agree, but that is ok right :0).Ok now back to looking up how to help a friend quit smoking.Trying hard,how to help a friend quit smoking.

Anonymous said...


business to business - Business Opportunity - Use Blog To Make Your Business Profitable.
Make money from blogs by getting people to read & respond.

The popularity of blogs helps people to improve the way they present themselves. Go the the search engine for blogs that may relate to your business. You would be surprised that most companies in your field probably already has blogs.

It is time for you to get started. Don't wait for your competitors. You can improve your business with potential customers and increased ranking on the search engines in a short time and at minimal cost.is EASY to set up when you know how to do it. Business Opportunity business to business

Anonymous said...

increase semen I have found a proven technique anyone can implement to very simply enlarge their love-muscle in very little time and effort. I've been able to generate an extensive gain in size and girth. This product is the most effective I've found online. People just like you attaining the gains they fancy with very little struggle. Stop stressing about a little love-muscle, dwindling confidence, never leave your mate unsatisfied again, and start on living your life the way YOU choose with a bigger, harder, and wider male member! - Please visit increase semen

Anonymous said...

penile pill I have found a proven approach anybody can implement to very easily enlarge their penis in very little time and effort. I've been able to create a sizeable gain in size and girth. This product is the most effective I've found online. Consumers just like you obtaining the gains they want with very little effort. Stop worrying about a small phallus, low confidence, never leave your mate unsatisfied again, and start living your life the way YOU pick with a bigger, harder, and wider penis! - Please visit penile pill

Anonymous said...

Hey, pretty nice blog you have here. Do you know anything about blog templates? I just can't seem to get it to work.


Thanks Pat
hoodia gordonii review

Anonymous said...

290th blog , been blogging all day,and came across yours.. looking

good, just looking for ideas for my own.

Thank,
Pat
how to effective ab workouts

Anonymous said...

Nice blog. Keep up the good work.

Regards,
Stock Options Trader
option trading tip

Anonymous said...

Nice blog and info. Keep up the good work.

I have a site that you are welcome to see at http://www.forex-affiliate.com/Affiliates/main.aspx?ref=5836 it is all about mini forex

Anonymous said...

I was searching blogs,and I found yours.Please,
accept my congratulations for your excellent work!
If you have a moment, please visit my tweety bird party supplies site.
Have a good day!

Anonymous said...

Hi Friend! You have a great blog over here!
Please accept my compliments and wishes for your happiness and success!
If you have a moment, please take a look at my stock price history site.
Have a great day!

Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a airfare consolidators site.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Greetings.

Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a airfare consolidators site.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Greetings.

Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a airfare specials from travel agencies site.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Greetings.

Anonymous said...

As always, you have compiled a very interesting blog here. I think you would enjoy my penis enlargement products blog. You should check it out if you are interested in all things related to penis enlargement products

Anonymous said...

After I took these pills, I couldn't believe I made love all night to my girlfriend, the next morning her cat jumped on my lap and I was ready to go again. For help with penis pills, give Vicerexlabs a try.

Anonymous said...

Excellent blog. weight loss diets Need to lose weight fast? Check out tips and information on my blog. Please visit weight loss diets

Anonymous said...

Nice blog. I wanted to share my experience with erection enhancers. I tried the little blue pills and experienced a stuffed up nose and blue halo in my vision that disrupted my whole evening, yeah I got an erection but I could not breath thru my nose, It left me frustrated. I have since tried many popular pills as seen on TV, and took them as directed for months, and none of them worked at all, so I gave Vicerex a try and wow was I amazed, not only did I get an erection in 20 minutes as claimed, but I also got aroused again seeing women and had sexual energy and desire and was able to have a controlled erection for days.

Anonymous said...

adult personals