Wednesday, April 27, 2005

A Better Memory: The Peculiar Persistence of Israel in Texts and DNA

Why did the Bible outlast Babylon? Millions of people, over and over, from the returning Judean exiles to the early Church to people of faith today, claim to be the "real Israel." Many acquire a new past, others actively choose to invoke and remember an old one, others forget. Is conversion a form of recovered memory, a kind of identity fraud? What do different people who claim to be part of the "real Israel" have in common? Scholars of religion and anthropology, as well as Biblical historians, struggle over what it means to convert and what kind of pasts are authentic.

What fascinates me is when it turns out that the early history of something--let's say, the invention of the memory of Israel--can shed light on its subsequent history, not because the origins tell you everything, but because a kind of internal logic might be revealed that is played out over and over again, different and the same in different ways each time.

This sometimes requires going back in time to before we even realize something was invented. My colleague and namesake Seth Richardson studies Babylonian history. I popped into his office today to say hi and talk about ancient political theory, as is my wont. Spying a book on his desk, we launched into a short talk on a crucial event in ancient Near Eastern history: the meeting of the (semi)nomadic concept of "the people" as the protagonist of politics and ritual with the technology of writing. The book that sparked it was Daniel Fleming's fantastic Democracy's Ancient Ancestors , a close look at the first time nomadic politics encountered writing, in the Old Babylonian city-state of Mari. Here politics wasn't defined by borders in space (the matum "land" or alum "settlement") but by kinship. The political relationships this system creates between people could persist across space and, once imagined in writing, across time as well. The written image of a "people" created an amazingly powerful model for emulation. Why?

Seth's one-liner: "it makes for a better memory."

I thought this was a beautiful way to get at the power of the concept of Israel as an imagined--and real--community that flows around the borders of states and persists across space and time. The people as fact and symbol, legal fiction and memory. And I'm not the first to be enchanted by it. Indians and British, South African Lemba and Nigerian Igbo have all imagined themselves to be lost tribes of Israel. What's stunning is when genetic evidence shows that some of them actually are.

The crucial thing about the genetic evidence is that, while it's hard science, it instantly becomes culture as soon as people think about it and do anything with it. While such proof changes everything, in other ways it changes nothing. The struggles over identity and meaning--encapsulated in the way that DNA itself becomes a symbol--continue. In this article, Invisible Races, written for the African/American race and culture journal Transition, I investigate how the Bantu-speaking Lemba, who have an unquestionable DNA link to the ancient Israelite priesthood, complicate the already dizzying "who is a Jew" argument.

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

Cool Blog! If you get a chance I would like to invite you to visit the following CD Blog. it is cool to!

Anonymous said...

Ja das ist fantastish!
buy viagra
cheap viagra online
Bye

Anonymous said...

Good evening, you are the best.
My site here [url=http://viagra-store.info/]viara[/url].
Take http://viagra-store.info#viagra best.
Bye.

Anonymous said...

Wazzup, interesting information.
my page [url=http://www.youthpeer.org/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=327]viara[/url].
Here you can buy http://www.youthpeer.org/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=327#viagra cheap.
thanks a lot.

Anonymous said...

Hello, best.
go here [url=http://www.theologicalforum.org/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=58]phentermine[/url].
Take http://www.theologicalforum.org/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=58#phentermine best.
thanks a lot.

Anonymous said...

Hey, interesting information.
Look at my site [url=http://bowtrol-herbal.info]viagra[/url].
Test http://bowtrol-herbal.info#viagra online.
Bye-bye.

Anonymous said...

The genetic legacy of Israel is obviously amazing, and part of the fulfillment of the promise to be "as numerous as the stars." One of the most geographically distant cases of these is that of the Lemba, as you have commented on before.

I was reading your Invisible Races article about the Lemba in Transitions, but I also came across some information about a group of Jewish ancestry in the region called the Ha-Redeye.

This looks like the missing puzzle piece that many have been looking for in trying to figure out exactly how the Lemba reached the African interior.

I know that there were a lot of Yemenis who migrated to the region, and I was wondering what you would make of it?

Anonymous said...

Hello, Please check out some relevant information about diet Pills and marriage

index.html index1.html soma akane soma other soma triathlon soma carisoprodol or purchase soma prescription soma and this :soma slim interesting: index.html index1.html cialis levitra cialis dissolving generic mouth look this cialis pack sample 20mg cialis cialis index2.html buy cialis link move online cialis com and look this cialis discount cialis generic online interesting:cialis liquid cialis sample pack generic cialis price and very creative : index.html buy viagra cheap viagra generic viagra buy viagra online viagra online free viagrabranded viagra gel tab viagra viagra viagra cialis levitra free viagraviagra side effects viagra prescription viagra uk and elseviagra retail discount viagra cost and look this index.html 2dir tramadol buy tramadol and very creative :tramadol order tramadol and this :cod tramadol 50 hcl mg tramadol and pill tramadol or |index.html zoloft side effects mayo zoloft for premature ejaculation weaning off zoloft zoloft litigation viagra online zoloft pmdd zoloft online zoloft zoloft common side effects or zoloft side affect and elsecelexa zoloft buy zoloft claritin reditabs and this :claritin d12 claritin d side effects claritin for dog online side affect of claritin interesting: index.html zithromax antibiotic medication zithromax for stds interesting:zithromax tri pack or index1.html zyrtec medication zyrtec tablet and very creative :zyrtec syrup child and very creative :diflucan pahrmacy diflucan side effects diflucan overnight imitrex coupon imitrex and serotonin index.html lipitor memory thief lipitor co q10 and lipitor effects lipitor liver side pfizer lipitor gain keyword neurontin weight neurontin lawsuit neurontin withdrawal neurontin addiction effects gain neurontin side weight kamagra sildenafil cheap citrate sildenafil zenegra generic sildenafil citrate sildenafil viagra citrate mexican sildenafil zenegra
.Good luck!

Anonymous said...

Hello, I find this sites index.html. It`s map s
ite index.html. and index2.html. and very creative : index.html.
s1.org/sildenafil/index.html>index.html.
zoloft litigation zoloft pmdd claritin hives clariten allergy medicine and claritin diflucan for infant thrush imitrex
/pills1.org/lipitor/effects-lipitor-negative-side.html>effects lipitor negative side
blister effects lipitor side lipitor lawsuit neurontin pfizer
-sildenafil-zenegra.html>cheap citrate sildenafil zenegra
or 100mg citrate sildenafil zenegra plant sildenafil zenegra G'night

Anonymous said...

viagra cheap good pharmacypharmacy austinpharmacypharmacy austin

Anonymous said...

Hi people! I am agree with all argument ...
index.html index1.html soma soma 350mg other soma triathlon soma online and soma fm buy cheap soma online and very creative :soma addiction interesting: index.html index1.html cialis online cialis generic viagra or buy cialis online 20mg cialis and buy cialis generic buy discount cialis cheap cialis online purchase and very creative :cialis drug generic minuteviagra online viagra cialis hz relurl.com look this cialis link online snap cialis st purchase cialis other index.html buy viagra cheap viagra generic viagra buy viagra online viagra online or inurl trackback viagra gel tab viagra viagra viagra cialis levitra and elseindex1.html viagra pill discount viagra online or norco viagra order viagra air travel cool info : index.html 2dir tramadol buy tramadol cool info : buy online tramadol effects side tramadol and hydrochloride tramadol hci tramadol tramadol online 100mg tramadol other |index.html zoloft side effects mayo zoloft for premature ejaculation weaning off zoloft zoloft litigation other zoloft pmdd interesting: zoloft zoloft information or wellbutrin vs zoloft and look this zoloft experience or claritin d 12 hour and claritin d durante noche claritin d side effects claritin dosage and very creative :claritin hives relief or zithromax generic zithromax antibiotic medication cheap zithromax and this :cost mart wal zithromax and very creative :zyrtec syrup zyrtec cetirizine hci claritin zyrtec allegra interesting:zyrtec for hives or diflucan yeast infection diflucan and pregnancy diflucan one generic imitrex imitrex medication index.html blister effects lipitor side lipitor rhabdomyolysis complication lipitor lipitor and pregnancy lipitor prices gain keyword neurontin weight drug neurontin neurontin used for neurontin addiction long term side effects of neurontin index1.html cheapest citrate sildenafil zenegra sildenafil softabs zenegra sildenafil side effects sildenafil soft tab zenegra

. Much respect!

Anonymous said...

Spiritual Thoughts

Spiritual approaches to consciousness involve the idea of altered states of consciousness or religious experience. Changes in the state of consciousness or a religious experience can occur spontaneously or as a result of religious observance. It is also maintained by some religions and religious factions that the universe itself is consciousness.

Anonymous said...

Hi! Good resources here. Very useful.
index.html soma ash of soma and else soma triathlon buy soma interesting:cheap soma soma sale and this :soma slim else index.html cialis online cialis dissolving generic mouth and this :cialis pack sample best cialis price and look this buy cialis in the uk buy cialis in uk buying generic cialis buy cialis online cialis drug cialis inurl permalink,guid and cialis pill cialis purchase online pharmacy meds cialis and this : buy viagra cheap viagra generic viagra buy viagra online order viagra cool info : inurl trackback viagra gel tab viagra viagra viagra cialis levitra viagra online viagra side effects viagra cialis viagra uk and viagra prescription online viagra sales tramadol online 2dir tramadol buy tramadol and elseonline tramadol hcl tramadol and very creative :apap tramadol 50mg hcl tramadol and overdose tramadol cool info : | zoloft side effects mayo zoloft for premature ejaculation weaning off zoloft zoloft litigation look this zoloft and pms and this : zoloft zoloft withdrawal and very creative :online zoloft other anxiety social zoloft buy zoloft claritin hives interesting:claritin redi tab claritin coupon medication claritin side effects and claritin clarinex and zithromax antibiotic zithromax z pack zithromax medication and look this dose pediatric zithromax and this :verkaufen zyrtec zyrtec zyrtec medication side effects and look this singulair zyrtec or diflucan thrush fluconazole diflucan canada diflucan buy imitrex online imitrex tablet doctor lipitor vs zocor lipitor loss memory 10mg lipitor cancer lipitor effects lipitor liver side lipitor loss weight 300mg neurontin neurontin gabapentin neurontin information neurontin and bipolar long term side effects of neurontin kamagra sildenafil jelly kamagra oral sildenafil kamagra oral sildenafil yelly cheap sildenafil zenegra 100mg kamagra sildenafil tablet

.Bye

Anonymous said...

Hi dude! Good job guys!
index.html index1.html soma akane soma look this argento soma soma carisoprodol or aura soma soma cube look this soma institute or index.html index1.html cialis levitra cheap cialis and very creative :cialis free best cialis price cool info : buy cialis generic buy cialis online statistics usage cheap cialis generic online or cialis compare viagra cialis generic online pharmacy us or cialis online rezeptfrei free cialis online pharmacy meds cialis cool info : index.html buy viagra cheap viagra generic viagra buy viagra online female viagra or discount viagra gel tab viagra viagra viagra cialis levitra and look this viagra side effects herbal viagra viagra sale look this good society viagra viagra forum other index.html 2dir tramadol buy tramadol buy tramadol buy online tramadol tramadol ultram cool info : 100 tramadol generic tramadol and elsecanine tramadol other |index.html zoloft side effects mayo zoloft for premature ejaculation weaning off zoloft zoloft litigation or ocd zoloft look this zoloft zoloft common side effects and elsezoloft sexual side effects buy zoloft zoloft interaction and look this index.html and this :claritin generic claritin child claritin side effects and this :claritin d prescription and this : index.html zithromax azithromycin zithromax chlamydia and look this funchain.com zithromax and look this 10mg antihistamine zyrtec zyrtec zyrtec 10mg and very creative :zyrtec d 12 other diflucan yeast infection diflucan diflucan over the counter imitrex side effects imitrex sumatriptan doctor lipitor vs zocor lipitor loss memory lipitor rhabdomyolysis complication lipitor effects lipitor medication side lipitor loss weight gain keyword neurontin weight neurontin neurontin side effect drug effects neurontin side treatment neurontin memory loss kamagra sildenafil fissure rectal sildenafil zenegra gastroparesis sildenafil zenegra buy sildenafil citrate indian sildenafil zenegra

.Sincerely

Anonymous said...

Hi! Take your time to visit some helpful info in the field of
catalog soma other soma 350mg soma triathlon best Soma buy cheap soma or porn star soma look this index cialis online cialis dissolving generic mouth cialis cialis pack sample awstats by cialis created online cialis free buy cheap cialis generic online tadalafil vs best cialis buy cialis online dream pharmaceutical and cialis cialis com look this cialis discount online cialis generic online price buy cialis online cialis pill cialis price purchase cheap cialis online other catalog buy viagra cheap viagra generic viagra buy viagra online female viagra and this :branded viagra gel tab viagra viagra viagra cialis levitra and very creative :free viagra sample natural viagra viagra uk and levitra vs viagra viagra on line interesting: catalog 2dir tramadol buy tramadol and look this tramadol cool info : hci tramadol zoloft online |catalog zoloft side effects mayo zoloft for premature ejaculation weaning off zoloft zoloft litigation viagra online zoloft pmdd zoloft zoloft zoloft weight loss or zoloft withdrawal effects and very creative :claritin d12hour interesting:claritin dosage or claritin effects loratadine side cool info : zithromax antibiotic drug zithromax or zithromax uti and look this zyrtec syrup zyrtec and pregnancy or symptom for zyrtec or diflucan thrush buy imitrex imitrex overnight the Lipitor catalog grapefruit lipitor buy cheap lipitor lipitor dosage the neurontin catalog best neurontin neurontin and bipolar the best sildenafil catalog sildenafil side effects information kamagra sildenafil

. Much respect!

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the welcome Yes,You may find it interesting to visit the pages :
tramadol and else lipitor or buy-soma viagra pharmic buy tramadol 2dir tramadol buy tramadol free tramadol cheap tramadol tramadol buy tramadol drug tramadol cool info : 50mg tramadol freetramadol information tramadol 180 tramadol or blog comment post tramadol buy cod tramadol and this : drug test tramadol and look this zoloft litigation zoloft zoloft pmdd and zoloft zoloft effects look this zoloft child zoloft and sex soma and this : soma cube cool info : soma overdose buy cialis online cialis viagra cialis free cialis free cialis free buy cialis online dreampharmaceuticals cialis cialis for sale cialis free cialis sale online viagra cheap viagra and very creative : viagra cool info : effects of viagra and this : canada online pharmacy viagra buy zoloft claritin hives interesting: claritin ingredient online zithromax generic zithromax antibiotic medication other pfizer zithromax or zyrtec cetirizine hci and zyrtec allergy treatment and this : diflucan 150mg online information on imitrex interesting: grapefruit lipitor lipitor statin
. Much respect!

Anonymous said...

Hi all! I bookmarked this guestbook. Thank you for good job! buy viagra cheap viagra
generic viagra buy viagra online viagra
online
female viagra and look this order viagra
discount viagra blindness viagra gel
tab viagra
viagra viagra alternative
viagra sample viagra cialis levitra
free
viagra sample
tramadol or lipitor or buy-soma
href='http://viagra-www.blogspot.com'>viagra
or herbal viagra and viagra cialis else viagra prescription and else viagra uk cool info : buy viagra cheap
other pfizer viagra cool info : mexican viagra other buying viagra
look this buy viagra on line
and very creative :levitra vs viagra and look this viagra research and else viagra retail discount else viagra canada viagra viagra use
interesting:cialis levitra sales viagra
and archive inurl trackback viagra
and this :female viagra cream and else herbal viagra and else cialis vs viagra levitra and
free sample viagra and cialis viagra and sale viagra viagra information viagra
cool info :
cialis generic viagra and dosage viagra
or use viagra
cool info : cheapest viagra
and buy cheap generic viagra and this :buy online order viagra
.Sincerely . Much respect!

Anonymous said...

Hi dude! Really an excellent site - it's always a pleasure to come back
pharmic and else 2dir tramadol buy tramadol tramadol online cheap tramadol tramadol ultram freetramadol prescription tramadol tramadol apap tramadol and else cheap online tramadol line tramadol other blog comment post tramadol day next tramadol and this : info tramadol or zoloft for premature ejaculation and look this zoloft night sweats other zoloft zoloft withdrawal other paxil zoloft lexapro vs zoloft soma look this buy cheap soma interesting: soma abuse and else cialis online or cialis and else cheapest cialis generic cool info : cialis levitra vs cialis free order cialis look this buy viagra online look this discount viagra viagra online cialis compare levitra viagra cool info : viagra levitra cool info : claritin hives or claritin d side effects and look this zithromax generic zithromax information and this :funchain.com zithromax online 10mg antihistamine zyrtec cool info : zyrtec 10mg tablet and else alcohol diflucan or imitrex side affect and very creative : joint lipitor pain effects gain neurontin side weight

.Bye

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the welcome diet pills for brides ???
index.html index1.html soma soma 350mg or ash lyric soma soma online cheap soma soma fm soma com soma drug soma institute cool info : index.html index1.html cialis levitra cialis dissolving generic mouth and else cialis pack sample best cialis price cialis online buy cialis generic buy tadalafil cialis buying cialis online and this :cialis drug viagra vs cialis generic price cool info : cialis me.com compare viagra to cialis generic cialis online viagra online index.html buy viagra cheap viagra generic viagra buy viagra online viagra online and elseinurl trackback viagra gel tab viagra viagra viagra cialis levitra and very creative :viagra alternative natural viagra purchase viagra interesting:natural viagra alternative viagra erection or index.html 2dir tramadol buy tramadol and look this tramadol acetaminophen hcl par tramadol and 100 tramadol sale tramadol look this buy cheap online tramadol or |index.html zoloft side effects mayo zoloft for premature ejaculation weaning off zoloft zoloft litigation and zoloft night sweats and zoloft zoloft overdose and look this zoloft withdrawal side effects or and claritin d 12 hour online claritin generic claritin claritin advertisement and this :benadryl and claritin and index.html zithromax for strep throat zithromax for child and drug more use zithromax look this index.html zyrtec d12hour zyrtec ingredient and this :pill zyrtec cool info : diflucan pahrmacy generic diflucan diflucan and ring worm imitrex migraine information on imitrex index2.html grapefruit lipitor 10 lipitor mg crestor lipitor vs effects lipitor liver side lipitor side effects liver gabapentin neurontin neurontin node swollen neurontin for pain neurontin alcohol neurontin class action lawsuit kamagra sildenafil cheapest citrate sildenafil zenegra congestion nasal sildenafil zenegra citrate pfizer sildenafil 100mg kamagra sildenafil tablet

. Regards